Kelleys Island Real Estate

Welcome to Kelleys Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Lake Erie, Ohio. This charming island community, located in Erie County, offers a perfect blend of natural beauty, rich history, and a vibrant atmosphere that draws visitors and residents alike. Spanning just over 3 square miles, Kelleys Island is the largest American island in Lake Erie, making it an ideal destination for those seeking a peaceful retreat or a fun-filled adventure.

As you explore Kelleys Island, you'll be captivated by its stunning landscapes, including picturesque shores, lush parks, and scenic hiking trails. The island is home to the Kelleys Island State Park, where you can enjoy activities such as camping, fishing, and birdwatching. Don’t miss the chance to visit the famous Glacial Grooves, a geological wonder that showcases the island's unique history and formation.

Kelleys Island boasts a tight-knit community that welcomes visitors with open arms. The island is dotted with quaint shops, delightful restaurants, and cozy accommodations, ensuring that you have everything you need for a memorable stay. Whether you’re savoring fresh local cuisine or indulging in a relaxing evening by the water, the island's charm is sure to leave a lasting impression.

With its blend of outdoor activities, historical landmarks, and warm community spirit, Kelleys Island is more than just a destination; it’s a lifestyle. Whether you’re looking to invest in a vacation home or seeking a permanent residence, Kelleys Island offers a unique opportunity to embrace the beauty of island living in Ohio. Come discover the magic of Kelleys Island—your perfect slice of paradise awaits!

Newest Listings in Kelleys Island

$897,500

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5256936 MLS

This Hidden, Off-The Grid, Family Compound is Nestled on a Spacious Wooded 0.85-Acre Lot on the Island's North Side. This Pristine 4 Bed, 2.5 Bath Estate Offers Complete Privacy with the Relaxed Luxury of Island Living.From the Moment you Step Inside, You'll Notice the Exceptional Craftsmanship and Attention to Detail. Beautiful Hardwood Floors Flow Seamlessly Throughout the Entire Residence, Creating a Warm and Elegant Atmosphere. The Gourmet Kitchen is a Chef's Dream, Featuring High-End Quartz Countertops, Custom Cabinetry, and Premium Finishes, Perfect for Hosting Family Dinners, or Entertaining Guests.The Expansive Wrap-Around Porch is The Crown Jewel. Enjoy Your Morning Coffee, Evening Cocktails, or Cool Island Lake Breezes from This Family-Sized Shaded Porch. The 2+ Car Attached Garage is Generous in Size with Plenty of Extra Room for Island Essentials like Golf Carts, Boats, Bikes, and Water Toys (Currently Used as the Family's Game Room). Walk Down the Private Lane to The Island's North Bay to Spend Your Summer Days Swimming, Sunbathing, and Taking in Lake Erie's Finest Sunsets. Whether You're Looking for an Unforgettable Family Escape, or a High-Performing Vacation Rental, or a Tranquil Year-Round Haven, this Kelleys Island Gem Delivers. Call Today to Schedule Your Private Showing.

115 Beech, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

$897,500

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 20264396 MLS

This Hidden, Off-The Grid, Family Compound is Nestled on a Spacious 0.85 Acre Wooded Lot on the Island's North Side. This Pristine 4 Bed, 2.5 Bath Estate Offers Complete Privacy with the Relaxed Luxury of Island Living.From the Moment you Step Inside, You'll Notice the Exceptional Craftsmanship and Attention to Detail. Beautiful Hardwood Floors Flow Seamlessly Throughout the Entire Residence, Creating a Warm and Elegant Atmosphere. The Gourmet Kitchen is a Chef's Dream, Featuring High-End Quartz Countertops, Custom Cabinetry, and Premium Finishes, Perfect for Hosting Family Dinners, or Entertaining Guests.The Expansive Wrap-Around Porch is The Crown Jewel. Enjoy Your Morning Coffee, Evening Cocktails, or Cool Island Lake Breezes from This Family-Sized Shaded Porch. The 2+ Car Attached Garage is Generous in Size with Plenty of Extra Room for Island Essentials like Golf Carts, Boats, Bikes, and Water Toys (Currently Used as the Family's Game Room). Walk Down the Private Lane to The Island's North Bay to Spend Your Summer Days Swimming, Sunbathing, and Taking in Lake Erie's Finest Sunsets.Whether You're Looking for an Unforgettable Family Escape, or a High-Performing Vacation Rental, or a Tranquil Year-Round Haven, this Kelleys Island Gem Delivers.Call Today to Schedule Your Private Showing.

115 Beech, Kelleys Island

Courtesy of Simply Better Realty, LLC

$1,385,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 20263973 MLS

Rare waterfront property now available on the east shore of Kelleys Island! Welcome to your new island oasis at 232 McGettigan Lane. Direct waterfront with natural rock shoreline that contains glacial grooves over 18,000 years old. This 2022 constructed home checks all of the boxes. Quiet street with very low traffic. Direct home to shoreline property with no street in between. Imagine watching the sun rise over Lake Erie from the comfort of your home or patio. Meticulous construction with standout features including rough cut pine window corbels, copper downspouts/gutters, and caramel quartzite stone complimenting the exterior. Attention to detail is apparent. This home is currently set up as a short-term rental with everything in place for you to generate income if you so choose. The interior is immaculate with upgraded fixtures containing switches with dimmers, roll up screen storm doors, and low maintenance LVP flooring. The concrete floor crawlspace is insulated, conditioned, and clean (see photos). All furniture and appliances stay making this home truly turn-key. When arriving to this lakefront estate, guests are invited by the long winding driveway that leads up to the oversized 2 car garage. Expansive front and rear yards compliment the exterior. The stone shoreline requires zero maintenance or upkeep cost. This natural coastline has a shallow exit, with the rear stone expanding hundreds of feet back during low water events. Imagine discovering new grooves and fossils when the lake is low. See attached drone photos of this clear water and mesmerizing shallow dropoff. Mooring buoy anchored in place for your jet ski, kayak, or tender. Discover this well-kept secret on quiet McGettigan Lane. This home, garage, and septic system is all newer 2022 construction. Kelleys Island is laid back, family friendly, and has many establishments to enjoy. The state park, beaches, ferry service, and people here are amazing. Open house 10/10 2-4p and 10/11 11a-1p.

232 Mcgettigan Ln, Kelleys Island

Courtesy of KW Greater Cleveland Northeast

111 W Lakeshore Dr Unit 2B, Kelleys Island

$445,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 20263724 MLS

Kelleys Island condo with Lake Erie views, ground floor living, and green space right outside your door! This 2 bedroom, 2 full bath condo makes a great island getaway. Enjoy the lake view from the kitchen, dining area, living room and deck, with association maintained green space just beyond that feels like your own yard. Improvements include windows in 2019, COREtec flooring throughout the main living areas in 2021, updated kitchen countertop and backsplash in 2022, and a heat pump/central air system in 2023. Appliances and washer and dryer are included, with a new dishwasher in 2026. Association amenities include an in ground pool, picnic and charcoal barbecue area, basketball court, first floor storage unit, and assigned parking right in front of the building. Currently owner occupied and not being used as a rental.

111 W Lakeshore Dr Unit 2B, Kelleys Island

Courtesy of Century 21 Bolte Real Estate - Catawba

$529,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 20263596 MLS

AMAZING REDUCTION for a quick sale before the end of the year. Take advantage of this limited price slash!!! You'll fall in Love with this Charming 4 BR, 2 Bath island Getaway featuring rustic knotty pine and bright white shiplap throughout. Tucked away on a quiet street just minutes from downtown excitement, this home is built for entertaining. There's an outdoor oasis in the rear, complete with above ground pool, a large Cabana and poolside potty. A recent addition of low maintenance Trex Decking surrounds both the front porch and pool area for effortless upkeep. This property also has a proven rental history as Limestone Landing on KI. If you're interested in a money maker when you're not there yourself, this home is an ultimate island retreat.

203 Lower Cliff Dr, Kelleys Island

Courtesy of RE/MAX Quality Realty - Sandusky

$795,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 20263654 MLS

Are you looking for a Serene Personal Retreat, an Island Getaway or an Air B and B Investment... This property has it all....Nestled between the Ferry and Downtown this property is minutes from all the Charm and Amenities that Kelleys Island has to offer.This exceptional property sits on .54 acres and features 3 bedrooms / 2 full baths, a wrap around porch and a large detached 24 x 32 garage that includes electric, plumbed for a bath, and a loft.The main-floor primary suite offers a large bedroom ensuite w/ walk-in closet. and an additional full bathrooms on this level that makes hosting family and friends easy. Upstairs has two bedrooms.Enjoy Lake Erie Island Life at its finest with boating, fishing, wineries, Cedar Point, breweries, golfing, beaches and so much more.Hurry and book your private showing this one won't last long.

205 Chappell St, Kelleys Island

Courtesy of Howard Hanna - Port Clinton

$5,995,000

20263497 MLS

This is a rare opportunity to own and operate a successful, professionally managed hotel business on one of the Great Lakes most visited islands, Kelleys Island, the largest American island on Lake Erie and a premier Midwest tourism destination. The property is a best in class, one of a kind hotel that offers guests a relaxing getaway within a private enclave that feels far removed from the mainland.The business shows steady year over year lodging activity, supported by modern booking software that keeps operations organized and efficient. Its prime location overlooking Lake Erie gives guests memorable views and easy access to the island's most popular attractions.A new owner can turnkey this opportunity and retain the existing management team or take over the day-to-day operations. This flexibility allows you to step in at the pace that fits your goals, whether you prefer a hands-on role or a more passive approach supported by experienced staff.There is also an opportunity to enhance and grow the Tiki bar area near the water into another feature that can increase guest activity and add new potential for the business.Along with lodging income and on-site golf cart rentals, the property offers something that is difficult to match. The replacement cost of this property and its improvements would be staggering, making the existing operation and its location an exceptional value for an investor or a family looking for a lifestyle driven island business in a high demand waterfront market.Contact Co-Listing Agent Henry "Mac" Lehrer, CCIM with Hoty Enterprises, Inc. in Sandusky, OH mac@hoty.com or Managing Director Gabriel Shamay with Cushman & Wakefield Global Hospitality Group of Boca Raton, FLgabriel.shamay@cushwake.com to receive the Offering Memorandum

441 W Lakeshore Dr, Kelleys Island

Courtesy of Hoty Enterprises, Inc.

$467,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5243717 MLS

Completely Remodeled - Turn-Key ~ 2 Bedroom/ 2 Bath Lower Level Unit Overlooking the Quarry Pond. Early Morning Coffee In the Sun, Afternoons In the Shade On the Back Deck! Currently Used As A Vacation Home and Income Producing Rental. Common Areas Include: The Pool, Charcoal BBQ / Picnic Area, Basketball Court and Kids Fishing Area. Additional Private Storage Space Included.

111 W Lakeshore Unit 4B, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

$467,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 20263613 MLS

111 W Lakeshore Unit 4B, Kelleys Island

Courtesy of Simply Better Realty, LLC

$160,000

20262874 MLS

Discover the perfect place to Build your island dream! This unique offering includes four adjoining woodedparcels being sold together as one expansive property on desirable Beach Road on beautiful Kelleys Island. Surrounded bymature trees and backing up to the island's historic quarry' this property offers privacy, tranquility, and a beautifulnatural setting. Whether you're planning a year-round residence or a vacation retreat, you'll enjoy the peacefulsurroundings while being just minutes from beaches, marinas, restaurants, wineries, parks, and all the charm KelleysIsland has to offer. Opportunities to own a wooded property of this size in such a desirable location are rare. Don't missyour chance to own your own piece of island paradise!

Beach, Kelleys Island

Courtesy of Red 1 Realty

$160,000

5234447 MLS

Discover the perfect place to Build your island dream! This unique offering includes four adjoining wooded parcels being sold together as one expansive property on desirable Beach Road on beautiful Kelleys Island. Surrounded by mature trees and backing up to the island's historic quarry’ this property offers privacy, tranquility, and a beautiful natural setting. Whether you're planning a year-round residence or a vacation retreat, you'll enjoy the peaceful surroundings while being just minutes from beaches, marinas, restaurants, wineries, parks, and all the charm Kelleys Island has to offer. Opportunities to own a wooded property of this size in such a desirable location are rare. Don't miss your chance to own your own piece of island paradise!

Beach Road, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Teresa Maher, realtorteresamaher@gmail.com With Red 1 Realty, LLC

$749,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 20262801 MLS

Rare opportunity to bring your vision to life on Kelleys Island! Situated on 3.37 wooded acres, this property offers exceptional space, privacy, and flexibility to create your own island retreat. Whether you're looking to enjoy the property as it is, expand, or customize to suit your own vision, the acreage provides endless potential in a peaceful natural setting.Conveniently located near the Kelleys Island Land Field Airport, the property offers easy year-round accessibility while maintaining a private feel. Originally built in 1978 and remodeled in 2002, the three-bedroom home features an open-concept kitchen and living area designed for gathering and entertaining. Front and rear decks extend the living space outdoors, offering inviting places to relax and enjoy the beauty and comfort of island life. A spacious pole barn provides excellent storage space.This is your chance to own a special piece of Kelleys Island while enjoying the flexibility that a property of this size provides. Schedule your private showing today! Buyers and Buyer Agents should do their own due diligence. Measurements are approximate. Agent is relative of Seller.

522 Monaghan Rd, Kelleys Island

Courtesy of BHHS Professional Realty-CLE

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Simply Better Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

Kelleys Island Real Estate

Newest Listings in Kelleys Island

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?