Castalia Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Castalia, Ohio – a hidden gem nestled in Erie County that offers a perfect blend of small-town charm and modern convenience. With its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, Castalia is an ideal place for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a tranquil lifestyle without sacrificing accessibility to urban amenities.

The town is renowned for its rich history and vibrant local culture. You can explore the scenic trails of the nearby Sheldon Marsh State Nature Preserve, perfect for hiking and birdwatching, or take a leisurely stroll through the quaint downtown area filled with unique shops and delightful eateries. Castalia is also conveniently located just a short drive from the shores of Lake Erie, offering residents ample opportunities for boating, fishing, and enjoying the great outdoors.

For those looking to call Castalia home, you'll be pleased to know that the real estate market offers a variety of charming homes priced under $500,000. Whether you're searching for a cozy single-family home with a spacious yard or a modern townhouse with contemporary finishes, you'll find an array of options that cater to diverse tastes and budgets. The community's commitment to maintaining a family-friendly atmosphere ensures that you’ll feel right at home from the moment you arrive.

Investing in a home in Castalia not only provides you with a beautiful living space but also immerses you in a community that values connection and quality of life. Come discover the warmth and allure of Castalia, where your dream home awaits!

Newest Castalia Homes under $500,000

$349,900

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 20263404 MLS

Welcome home to this spacious 2,500 sq. foot home situated on a beautiful .56 acre lot! The inviting living room features a cozy gas fireplace and beautiful flooring that continues throughout the kitchen and dining area. The generously sized primary bedroom offers a walk in closet , with lots of cabinets for storage. There is also a private en suite bathroom for added comfort and convenience. There are two additional bedrooms with good closet space. A full basement provides abundant storage and many possibilities. The detached two- car garage offers plenty of space for vehicles and more. All appliances stay and the washer and dryer, making this home convenient and ready for the new owners! Don't miss out on making this spacious property your own! All measurements are approximates and should be independently verified by buyer and buyers agent.

115 Lowell St, Castalia

Courtesy of Bonnigson & Associates

$425,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 20263083 MLS

Welcome to the home you've been waiting for! Situated on just under 2 picturesque acres, this exceptional 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers the perfect blend of comfort, functionality, and flexibility.At the heart of the home is a beautiful open-concept kitchen and dining area designed for gathering, entertaining, and everyday living. Thoughtfully maintained and truly move-in ready, this home offers an abundance of storage throughout, ensuring there's a place for everything.The undeniable centerpiece is the private primary wing a retreat you'll never want to leave. Featuring a beautifully updated spa-like ensuite, an oversized walk-in closet, an additional secondary closet, and over 300 square feet of versatile bonus space, this incredible suite can be customized to fit your lifestyle. Create the ultimate dressing room, home gym, nursery, office, wellness retreat, sitting room, or anything else you can imagine. The possibilities are endless.The attached heated and cooled workshop is another standout feature. Whether you're a hobbyist, craftsman, or simply need an incredible workspace, it's ready to go or reimagine it as the ultimate game room, teen hangout, home business space, art studio, or additional flex room. The choice is yours. An oversized outbuilding provides even more storage for equipment, tools, lawn care items, or recreational toys.Outside, unwind on the spacious back deck overlooking nearly two acres of peaceful outdoor space with plenty of room to entertain, garden, or simply enjoy the privacy.Additional features include a whole-house propane backup generator and dual sump pumps in the crawlspace, providing added comfort and peace of mind.From its incredible storage and flexible living spaces to the one-of-a-kind primary retreat, this home offers endless opportunities to make it your own. Properties with this much space, versatility, and thoughtful design rarely come along don't miss your chance to call it home!

5008 Homegardner Rd, Castalia

Courtesy of North Bay Realty, LLC

$489,900

9 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 5202631 MLS

Multi-unit investment opportunity in a private setting! This unique property features a standalone 3-bedroom, 1-bath home with a full basement, plus a spacious duplex perfect for generating income or multi-generational living. The upper unit offers 4 bedrooms and 2 baths, while the lower unit includes 2 bedrooms and 2 full baths. Beautifully remodeled in 2017. Outside the 30' x 28' red barn adds storage, parking or a workshop. Whether you're an investor, entrepreneur, or someone looking for a family compound,the possibilities are truly endless. This property is commercially zoned. There's even potential to add a second 48' x 34' barn with additional acreage.

5414 Homegardner Road, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Megan C Huber, hubermegan86@gmail.com With Russell Real Estate Services

$489,900

20261331 MLS

Multi-unit investment opportunity in a private setting! This unique property features a standalone 3-bedroom, 1-bath home with a full basement, plus a spacious duplex perfect for generating income or multi-generational living. The upper unit offers 4 bedrooms and 2 baths, while the lower unit includes 2 bedrooms and 2 full baths. Beautifully remodeled in 2017. Outside the 30' x 28' red barn adds storage, parking or a workshop.Whether you're an investor, entrepreneur, or someone looking for a family compound, the possibilities are truly endless.This property is commercially zoned, but in the process of being switched to residential.

5414 Homegardner Rd, Castalia

Courtesy of Russell Real Estate Services - Sandusky

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Simply Better Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.