Italian Village / Short North Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Italian Village, a vibrant and eclectic neighborhood nestled in the heart of Columbus, Ohio, within Franklin County. This charming subdivision, part of the Short North Arts District, is a delightful blend of historic character and modern living. Known for its rich Italian heritage, Italian Village boasts stunning architecture, tree-lined streets, and a warm, community-oriented atmosphere.

One of the most appealing aspects of this neighborhood is its accessibility to a variety of homes priced under $500,000, making it an attractive option for first-time homebuyers, young professionals, and families alike. Here, you can find a diverse selection of properties, from beautifully renovated historic homes to contemporary townhouses, all reflecting the unique charm of the area.

Living in Italian Village means you’re just a stone’s throw away from the bustling Short North, where art galleries, trendy boutiques, and a plethora of dining options await. Enjoy a leisurely stroll down High Street, where you can immerse yourself in the local culture or indulge in the vibrant nightlife. The community is also known for its beautiful parks and green spaces, perfect for outdoor enthusiasts and families looking to enjoy some fresh air.

With its rich history, artistic flair, and an array of affordable housing options, Italian Village offers a lifestyle that’s both dynamic and inviting. Discover your dream home in this enchanting neighborhood, where the spirit of community thrives and every corner tells a story. Embrace the charm of Italian Village – your new home awaits!

Newest Italian Village / Short North Homes under $500,000

$395,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 226034091 MLS

Stylishly updated sunny 2-story shared-wall townhome-style single-family house (not a condo; no HOA or COA) w/lovely private patio, a short walk from base of Short North, Convention Center, Arena District, and popular Italian Village attractions. Buy it as a primary residence or turnkey furnished rental (currently a successful, licensed AirBnB short-term rental). Main level has spacious kitchen w/navy cabinets, butcher block counters & SS appliances; full dining room & large living room with/original fireplace & trim details. Upstairs has 2 private bedrooms and full bathroom. Larger bedroom has wall of built-ins for storage and home office. Recent improvements include new gas furnace & water heater (2026), Wi-Fi enabled Schlage keypad deadbolt locks, Nest thermostat, and Ring Video Doorbells helpful for managing STR tenancies. Short North Parking Plan Zone SNB street parking pass available for $25/yr. Showings need to be scheduled around current AirBnB stays.

729 Kerr Street, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Nathan R Caplin ---- CapOhio Real Estate

$369,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 226033197 MLS

Italian Village | Columbus, OH | 2 BD | 1.5 BA Location is the first thing buyers notice here, and it delivers. This two-bedroom, 1.5 bath townhome sits on a quiet street in Italian Village, one of Columbus' most walkable and in-demand neighborhoods, with the Short North, Goodale Park, and some of the city's best restaurants and coffee shops nearby. The address alone puts this property on a short list. Inside, hardwood floors run throughout the main living areas. Tall ceilings and exposed brick add the kind of architectural character that newer construction cannot replicate. Natural light moves through the space generously, making it feel larger than the square footage suggests. The kitchen includes newer stainless steel appliances and connects to a large dining area, keeping the main level open and functional. A gated entry provides a sense of arrival and added privacy that stands out in an urban setting. Upstairs, two spacious bedrooms both feature vaulted ceilings. The bathroom has been completely renovated with a walk-in shower, soaking tub, and double sinks. Step outside to a private, fenced patio. For a property this close to the energy of the Short North, having an outdoor space that actually feels removed from it is a meaningful feature. A basement includes a newer washer and dryer and adds storage. A one-car garage rounds out a package that is genuinely difficult to find at this location. This property functions equally well as a primary residence or an income-producing rental asset. Proximity to the convention center, Ohio State Medical Center, and the downtown employment core makes this an ideal location.

1103 Mount Pleasant Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Karen S Smith ---- The Brokerage House

$425,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 226032211 MLS

Historic Brick Home in Italian Village | 41 E Prescott Street Step into a piece of Columbus history at 41 E Prescott Street. Built in 1850, this charming brick home offers approximately 1,470 square feet of living space in the heart of Italian Village one of central Columbus's most desirable and walkable urban neighborhoods. Inside, you'll find two bedrooms, one full bathroom, one half bathroom, and comfortable living and dining areas with the flexibility to accommodate everyday living, entertaining, or working from home. Historic character and a classic brick exterior give the property its distinctive appeal, while offering an exciting opportunity to personalize the interior and make the home your own. The full basement provides valuable additional space for storage and household needs. Outside, the private patio creates an inviting setting for morning coffee, outdoor dining, entertaining friends, or relaxing at the end of the day. The manageable outdoor space delivers the benefits of city living without the maintenance demands of a large yard. Located in Columbus's Italian Village neighborhood, this home offers convenient access to the Short North Arts District, Downtown Columbus, neighborhood restaurants, coffee shops, shopping, entertainment, and major commuter routes. If you have been searching for a historic home for sale in Italian Village, a brick home near the Short North, or a centrally located Columbus property with character and potential, 41 E Prescott Street deserves a closer look. Open House: Sunday, 1:00-4:00 PM

41 E Prescott Street, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Joseph R Speakman ---- e-Merge Real Estate

$150,000

226021714 MLS

RARE OPPORTUNITY TO OWN ONE OF THE LAST AVAILABLE BUILDING LOTS IN HIGHLY DESIRABLE ITALIAN VILLAGE! Whether you're looking to build a custom owner-occupied residence or capitalize on an exceptional development opportunity, this property offers tremendous potential in one of Columbus' most sought-after neighborhoods. Surrounded by luxury new construction, with nearby homes selling from the upper $800,000s to well over $1 million, the possibilities are endless. Enjoy a premier location just steps from neighborhood shops, restaurants, parks, and the vibrant High Street and Short North districts. Conveniently located minutes from Downtown Columbus, The Ohio State University, and major employment centers. AGGRESSIVELY PRICED AND READY FOR DEVELOPMENT. OPPORTUNITIES LIKE THIS ARE BECOMING INCREASINGLY RARE IN ITALIAN VILLAGE!

1152 Summit Street, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Michael A Casey ---- RE/MAX Connection

$370,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 226018203 MLS

Live where historic charm and vibrant city energy come together in the heart of downtown Columbus. This beautifully maintained 2 bedroom, 2 full bath brick condo is just moments from the Short North, Italian Village, restaurants, nightlife, and coffee shops. Inside, soaring ceilings, oversized windows, rich hardwood floors, detailed woodwork, and a cozy fireplace create a warm and inviting atmosphere filled with character. The kitchen features granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, custom cabinetry, and timeless finishes that blend seamlessly with the home's historic feel. Spacious bedrooms offer comfortable retreats while the finished upper level provides flexible space for a home office, workout area, or creative studio. Enjoy quiet mornings on the covered front porch, evening walks through the city, and the convenience of rare off street parking in one of Columbus' most desirable urban locations. Call for your private showing today!

29 E 2nd Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Kerri Deel ---- Sluss Realty Company

$497,500

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 226017493 MLS

Welcome to 185 E 2nd Avenue, a beautifully updated home, offering over 2000 s.f. of FULLY FURNISHED living space, in the heart of Columbus' highly sought-after Italian Village--where historic charm meets modern city living. Whether you're looking for a stylish primary residence or a turnkey Airbnb investment, this property offers the flexibility and appeal to do both. This home comes furnished, making it ideal for immediate move-in or short-term rental use with minimal setup. Recent updates include fresh exterior paint and refreshed landscaping, enhancing curb appeal and creating an inviting first impression for guests or homeowners alike. Inside, you'll find a warm and functional layout that blends character with comfort--perfect for everyday living or hosting visitors. The surrounding neighborhood is one of Columbus' most vibrant, known for its walkability, energy, and proximity to everything. Living in Italian Village means you're just steps away from some of the city's best dining, coffee, and entertainment. Enjoy local favorites like Ravello's for morning coffee, The Market Italian Village for casual eats and drinks, and Seventh Son Brewing Co. for craft beer and community vibes. You're also minutes from the Short North Arts District, offering endless restaurants, boutiques, galleries, and nightlife. With its prime location, recent exterior improvements, and income-generating potential, 185 E 2nd Avenue is a rare opportunity to own a versatile property in one of Columbus' most desirable neighborhoods. *****All furniture and other items in the listing photos are included in the price of the home if Buyer wants them***

185 E 2nd Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Susan K Miller ---- Real of Ohio

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Simply Better Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.